House of Assembly: Vol13 - WEDNESDAY 10 MAY 1989
†Indicates translated version.
For written reply:
General Affairs:
asked the Minister of Constitutional Development and Planning:
- (1) What total number of persons could be accommodated as at 31 December 1988 in the (a) houses and (b) single quarters available in (i) Langa, (ii) Nyanga and (iii) Guguletu without there being undesirable overcrowding;
- (2) (a) how many persons are estimated to be living in these (i) houses and (ii) single quarters in (aa) Langa, (bb) Nyanga and (cc) Guguletu and (b) in respect of what date is this estimate furnished?
B607E
This matter vests in the Administrator of the Cape Province and he has furnished the following reply:
(1) |
(a) Houses |
(b) Single quarters (beds) |
|
(i) |
Langa (6,1) |
17 537 |
9 990 |
(ii) |
Nyanga (8,0) |
33 696 |
8 104 |
(iii) |
Guguletu (6,5) |
51 090 |
7 707 |
(2) (a) |
(i) |
(ii) |
|
Houses |
Single quarters |
||
(aa) |
Langa |
29 735 |
31 968 |
(bb) |
Nyanga |
36 562 |
25 933 |
(cc) |
Guguletu |
81 789 |
24 662 |
The recent number of inhabitants per main structure as indicated in brackets in (1) is regarded as normal acceptable occupation. The overcrowding occur per residential site and not per house. During the socioeconomic survey in October 1988 it was established that every hostel bed represents an average of 3,2 persons. The overcrowding, therefore, is most critical in regard of the single quarters. The reason for this is that single people live within a family relation in the single quarter units.
(b) Information as on 31 December 1988.
asked the Minister of Foreign Affairs:
- (1) Whether the holding of free and fair elections is one of the pre-conditions of a settlement in South West Africa; if so,
- (2) whether the parties participating in these elections will be permitted to receive financial support from foreign organizations; if so, what are the relevant details;
- (3) whether he and/or his Department will take measures to ensure that no party participating in these elections will obtain any unfair advantage over any other such parties; if not, why not; if so, what measures?
B714E
- (1) Yes.
- (2) Yes, subject to the provisions of the relevant international agreements and Resolution 435 of the Security Council of the UN.
- (3) In accordance with the provisions of Security Council Resolution 435 (1978) this is the task of the Administrator-General of South West Africa and the Special Representative of the UN Secretary-General.
asked the Minister of Defence:
- (1) Whether there has been a South African Defence Force presence (a) on the campus or in the immediate vicinity of the University of the North and (b) in the vicinity of the home of the rector of this university at any time since 1 January 1989; if so, (i) for what purpose, (ii) at whose request, (iii) for what periods, (iv) on what dates and (v) with what effect;
- (2) whether Defence Force personnel monitor or control in any way the movement of students arriving at or departing from the campus (a) during the day and (b) after hours?
B756E
It is normal practice not to disclose any information on the deployment, movement and utilization of the SA Defence Force. (1) and (2) Fall away.
asked the Minister of Defence:
- (1) How many (a) White, (b) Coloured, (c) Indian and (d) Black persons volunteered for national service in the South African Defence Force in 1988;
- (2) how many of these volunteers in each category could be accommodated?
B765E
(a) |
(b) |
(c) |
(d) |
|
(1) |
728 |
6 499 |
506 |
6 |
(2) |
211 |
3 111 |
400 |
0 |
Own Affairs:
Reply substituting reply to Question No 46 on 6 April 1989, put by Mr R M Burrows (col 568):
asked the Minister of Education and Culture:
How many teaching service bursaries and/or loans were made available in each provincial education department in the 1988-89 financial year?
B569E
Cape |
2 736 |
Natal |
1 634 |
OFS |
558 |
Transvaal |
8 545 |
The sign * indicates a translation. The sign †, used subsequently in the same interpellation, indicates the original language.
General Affairs:
asked the Minister of Defence:
Whether the South African Defence Force is occupying any portion of Khosies, which is situated between Kuruman and Postmasburg, or land surrounding Khosies or in its immediate vicinity; if so, what action has the Defence Force taken or does it intend taking in respect of the local inhabitants?
C99E.INT
Mr Chairman, the answer is as follows. The Gathlose-Marcmane area to which the hon member for Reigerpark is referring, was transferred to the South African Defence Force during January 1978 as a training site for the South African Army’s conventional forces.
The area was too limited for formation exercises, with the result that additional farms were expropriated and the area was enlarged to its present surface area. The land of the White farmers who were in the area had been expropriated already, and they had left the area some time before.
The presence of the community in the central part of the P W Botha Training Site has a restrictive effect on training. Various problems, including security, overgrazing and the safety of the inhabitants, are being experienced, and this has a negative influence on the effectivity of the army battle school. These are the aspects which necessitate that positive action be taken immediately to resettle the community.
It is becoming more and more difficult for the South African Defence Force to obtain suitable land for training and in the process it is often necessary to sacrifice the effectiveness of training for the sake of other interests. Various concessions have been made in this connection in the past and the South African Defence Force has often given up land for development.
As hon members know, this community is situated almost in the middle of the training site and the 14 000 ha grazing area restricts the usable training site to strips on the eastern, western and northern sides of the site. This position has an extremely detrimental effect on the use of the site, because it cannot be used to its maximum for formation exercises, and one can only manoeuvre and shoot around this particular area. In addition the training site has very few places where one can do water-obstacle training and practice creating bridgeheads.
Numerous accidents have taken place in this area. In 1978 a person died after picking up a 60mm mortar bombshell. In 1987 three children were killed and one seriously injured after picking up a hand grenade there. On various occasions during the years between 1978 and 1986 cattle belonging to these people were shot. In 1987 eight head of cattle were killed when, during a bombardment at night, they were in the target area where they were not supposed to have been. The continued presence of the community and their cattle on the training site hampers security. The SADF is extremely concerned about the inhabitants’ lives and their well-being, as well as the possible damage of their properties. That is why the SADF has shown great understanding and sympathy for more than 10 years … [Time expired.]
Mr Chairman, I want to react later to what the hon the Deputy Minister said in this connection. I merely find it interesting that he mentioned the year in which the land had been transferred to the Defence Force. The Gathlose-Marcmane area’s residents’ problem has existed since the days of the old CRC and it was the subject of intense discussion in that council among the people of that region. The late Oom Jan Ferris constantly bemoaned the fate of the people of that area and suggested solutions to establish the people’s permanence on that 14 000 ha of farming land—this was long before the Defence Force appeared on the scene.
The hon member Mr Muller and I were there ourselves on 29 April 1989. Slipping and sliding through the muddy paths and wallows, we paid our visit. [Interjections.] The poultry there are plump as partridges, the cattle are among the best I have seen, there is an abundance of natural drinking water and although the people are cut off from the nearest towns as well as from means of communication, they are as happy as can be. They want to stay there. The hon the Deputy Minister must tell us what they are going to do in connection with those people. They want the Government’s absolute assurance that they can stay there permanently and will even be able to get title deeds for every family on that land that they call crown land, reserve land, trust land or—as one old woman there said—Oom Paul Kruger’s land. The people stay there free of charge, and they want it kept that way. At the moment they are living in prefabricated buildings and they now want to have decent houses built for themselves. These can then be permanently retained for the children.
It looks as though the Defence Force is subtly trying to lure the people from there to neighbouring towns, however. The Defence Force built four houses at Postmasburg, and then told the people that the houses were ready and that they could move. Later these people then found that they had to pay rent, as well as pay for water and other services, whereas that is not the case at Gathlose-Marcmane. The residents are terribly dissatisfied and unhappy about this. One of them has moved back already. A witty grandfather summed up the situation by saying: “The Government blindfolded us like donkeys drawing bucket pumps. Postmasburg’s former management committee put blinkers on us as if we were transport donkeys.” It is a long time since I heard that kind of language and I found it terribly interesting. This situation … [Time expired.]
Mr Chairman, I should like to tell the hon the Deputy Minister of Defence that I think it is absolutely essential for the residents of this area to gain certainty with regard to their future. According to my information these people do not know whether they have to stay there or leave. This community is essentially a farming community, and I understand that some of them are reasonably successful farmers. Consequently it would be unfair in my opinion to expect these people to settle in a town. According to the information given by the hon the Deputy Minister, I understand that such a possibility is being considered. Then there is also the possibility of a tragedy such as those indicated by the hon the Deputy Minister and the one which has taken place in this area. We know that there was a tragedy on the Defence Force’s Rooiberg Training Site on the West Coast earlier this year when two children were killed and a number of children were injured.
I think it is extremely important to reach finality so that the people can know what their fate and their future will be. They must know whether they will be able to stay there and carry on with their farming or not, and if not, where they will be going to.
Mr Chairman, I merely want to ask the hon the Deputy Minister to what extent the people are going to be compensated if it is decided to move them. [Interjections.]
Mr Chairman, the branch committee of the LP in the area has been dealing with the problem at Khosies for some time now and numerous discussions have been held with the hon the Minister of Local Government, Housing and Agriculture.
This hon Minister put reasonable options to the community, including alternative settlement at a mining town, Owendale, and also somewhere along the Botswana border. These options appear to be unacceptable to these people, and the attitude of the party in this region is that these people will not be forced to accept any option, but that the community will be given the choice of taking a decision themselves on where they want to settle.
Houses were built for these people at Kuruman during the early eighties. These houses have already been sold to the community in Kuruman because the people of Khosies did not want to move there. [Interjections.]
One of the solutions in this area appears to be for the Army to relinquish 14 000 ha on the one side of the Defence Force site to the community so that they can be settled there. Then they will be out of the way of the Defence Force and decent access roads can be built. In addition decent camps can be fenced off for their cattle, which will solve the problem of overgrazing. One can ultimately move in the direction of a situation where the land can be registered in the names of the individuals, since the settlement as it is at present is quite unacceptable because it is collectively owned. No individual person owns the land, and consequently there is no desire to take extra care when it comes to matters such as overgrazing. As a result the department cannot construct proper roads for the community. [Interjections.]
In conclusion I want to give hon members the assurance that we shall resolve this problem together with the community of Khosies in co-operation with the Ministers’ Council and the responsible Government departments.
Mr Chairman, the hon member who is bragging so about what the LP is doing about the problem did not say that the hon member for the area, Northern Cape, had collected money from the people in order to come to Parliament to put their case here and that absolutely nothing had been decided with regard to the people’s future; on the contrary, they will be surprised to hear that they are no longer all that welcome there. [Interjections.]
Since the hon the Minister has said that the Defence Force wants to use that area, it is absolutely essential that there be clarity in respect of the people’s settlement. There is water available adjacent to that land, and the Defence Force must think of that. The people cannot possibly move to the cities with their farming activities. [Interjections.]
In addition signs have been erected there by the Defence Force saying that it is dangerous to pick up unexploded bombs, mortars, hand grenades, etc. What does one do about the illiterates that live in Khosies? How can they read those signs put up by the Defence Force?
The Defence Force should have taken into account the representations addressed to them years ago by the old CRC and even prior to that. The late Oom Jan Ferris said he had initiated representations in this connection as early as 1946, before they moved in there and endangered the cattle and property and lives of those farmers. That is the point on which the hon the Minister must give us clarity. The hon member Mr Lockey must not say he has spoken to the hon the Minister of Local Government, Housing and Agriculture. Those people do not want to be settled in an urban area. They want to be where they can farm. [Interjections.] That is what happens if they do not do their work. [Time expired.]
I thank all the hon members who have taken part in the interpellation so far. I want to assure hon members that the SA Defence Force has handled
this matter with great circumspection, sympathy and understanding for that community in the past, and will continue to do so in future. The hon member Mr Lockey is quite correct in saying that we must find ways of resettling that community in their interests and in consultation with them. I believe we can move them to a better place than where they are now.
Reference was made to this community as if they were all farmers. I have information which can prove to hon members that in reality there are only three bona fide farmers. The others are owners of cattle and the rest of the community is not very literate. The people have been there since 1945. Since then they have obtained a right to be there. The SADF acknowledges that right. If they must be moved, these people have the right to be compensated and to be placed in a community where they can afford to live. They do not own the land; the White farmers who owned land were expropriated and they had to purchase other land for themselves on the open market. We are prepared to do exactly the same for this community. We are prepared to compensate them sufficiently for the losses they might incur there. I have confidence in the Ministers’ Council of this House and I believe that they will take care of individual members of that community who end up in other communities. I see the hon the Chairman of the Ministers’ Council is sitting here and I know he will agree with me. I am confident that they will do that.
I want to appeal to hon members of this House and of the Ministers’ Council to seek the best possible solution for this community hand in hand, without reproaching one another. The SADF needs this land to train hon members’ and my sons. There are no other available areas. [Interjections.] We had to relinquish land for training on the West Coast recently, in order to make room for development for Coloured people on the West Coast. The SADF has always been prepared to do its share to grant assistance. We must have enough room to practise properly somewhere, however. Armscor had a wonderful show in Turkey, which earned a great deal of foreign exchange for this country. We must have somewhere to test those weapons, however, and this is such a site. [Time expired.]
Debate concluded.
†Indicates translated version.
For oral reply:
General Affairs:
asked the Minister of Water Affairs:
- (1) Whether farmers’ organizations in the Alexandria and Patterson areas in the Eastern Cape have applied for irrigation district status; if so, (a) when and (b) for what purpose;
- (2) whether any areas in the Eastern Cape have been proclaimed irrigation districts; if so, which areas;
- (3) whether it is his intention to have water from the Orange River brought to the Bushmans River; if so, when; if not, why not;
- (4) whether he will make a statement on the matter?
C87E
- (1) Yes.
- (a) 4 June 1985
- (b) To construct a combined system of water works for the abstraction of water from the Fish-Sundays River System for use in the Bushmans River Valley and to specifically control the use of water in the Bushmans River.
- (2) Yes, a number of irrigation districts have been proclaimed, viz:
Name of Board |
District |
Baroda |
Cradock |
Boschberg |
Somerset East |
Brakrivier |
Cradock/Middelburg |
Commandodrift |
Cradock |
Doornrivier |
Indwe |
Gaunavlakte |
Cradock |
Groot-Visrivier |
Cradock |
Hougham-Abrahamson |
Somerset East |
Katrivier |
Cradock/Fort Beaufort |
Klein-Visrivier |
Somerset East |
Klipfontein |
Somerset East |
Knutsford |
Cradock |
Kubusrivier |
Stutterheim |
Marlow |
Cradock |
Middelton |
Somerset East |
Mortimer |
Cradock |
Renfield |
Bedford |
Scanlen |
Cradock |
Somerset-Oos |
Somerset East |
Sondagsrivier |
Uitenhage |
Tarkaburg |
Cradock |
Van Rynevelds Pass |
Graaff-Reinet |
- (3) The possible supply of water to the Bushmans River area is still under investigation. This investigation includes the study of the economic and socio-economic benefits of such a water scheme and will also compare the benefits of other possible developments under the Orange River Development Project. The priorities of such possible developments must still be decided upon.
- (4) Yes. A statutory enquiry regarding the establishment of the irrigation district was held on 22 April 1987. The proclamation of the irrigation district can only be proceeded with when a viability report on a proposed scheme is available.
asked the Minister of Water Affairs:
- (1) Whether, during the construction of the wall of the Paul Sauer Dam, any problems were experienced in regard to the foundations of the dam; if so, what problems;
- (2) whether these problems have been solved; if not, why not; if so, in what manner;
- (3) whether these problems had any effect on the design capacity of the dam; if so, what effect;
- (4) whether he will make a statement on the matter?
C88E
- (1) Yes. During the excavation for the foundation on the right flank, unfavourable Phyllite seams were discovered requiring special attention.
- (2) Yes. The foundation problems were solved by implementing amongst others the following engineering solutions:
- (a) A change in the geometry of the wall;
- (b) provision of additional concrete and post-tensioned cables on the right flank to bind the rock layers; and
- (c) an extensive tunnel drainage system for the right flank.
- (3) No. The foundation problems were overcome by implementing the afore-mentioned engineering solutions, whereby the design capacity was retained.
- (4) Yes. The behaviour of the dam is being monitored continuously since construction and its performance thusfar can be described as satisfactory.
Mr Chairman, arising from the hon the Minister’s reply, does the dam carry the volume of water which it was originally intended to hold?
Mr Chairman, the dam can hold that volume of water, but on account of the drought there is no water. Nevertheless, I should like to point out to the hon member that this dam is also subject to our dam safety regulations. In other words, if the dam has any structural defect, the Department of Water Affairs will repair it in accordance with the law and regulations. The Department of Water Affairs will see to it. As a result this dam will be able to hold the full volume of water. Whether the water in the dam is sufficient to supply water to the areas that are of concern to the hon member for Bethelsdorp, is, however, a different question altogether.
For written reply:
General Affairs:
asked the Minister of Constitutional Development and Planning:†
- (1) (a) What percentage of the posts in his Department was filled by (i) Black, (ii) Coloured and (iii) Indian persons as at 1 March 1989 and (b) which posts were so filled;
- (2) (a) in respect of which senior posts in his Department were appointments made during the latest specified period of 12 months for which figures are available and (b) in which of these posts were (i) Black, (ii) Coloured and (iii) Indian persons appointed;
- (3) whether the posts concerned were advertised; if not, why not; if so, in what manner?
C61E
- (1)
- (a)
- (i) Black: 13% (in respect of the total establishment including labourer provisioning)
- (ii) Coloured: 0%
- (iii) Indian: 0%
These details should be viewed against the background that approximately 15% of this Department’s functions are of an executive nature. Therefore a comprehensive establishment does not exist.
- (b) 1 Assistant Trade and Industry Adviser
3 Senior Media Officers
1 Media Officer (second leg)
2 Temporary Chief Planning Administration Clerks
4 Senior Planning Administration Clerks
9 Planning Administration Clerks
29 Guards
32 Labourers
13 Messengers
7 Tea girls
- (a)
- (2)
- (a) Director: Planning (Economic Planning)
- (b) (i) to (iii) None
- (3) No. An expert in Economics who has already done work on contract for the Department was identified for appointment in this post.